This blog is still alive, just in semi-hibernation.
When I want to write something longer than a tweet about something other than math or sci-fi, here is where I'll write it.

Monday, January 25, 2010

Super Bowl XLIV

The match-up for the 43rd Super Bowl will star the top seeded teams from each conference, each lead by the quarterback who threw for the most touchdowns in his conference during the regular season. Peyton Manning and the Indianapolis Colts fell behind in the first half to the upstart New York Jets, but dominated the second half to win 30-17. Drew Brees and the New Orleans Saints won a back-and-forth nail-biter against the Minnesota Vikings, intercepting a Brett Favre pass in the last two minutes when the Vikings were driving for the go-ahead score with seconds left, forcing overtime and winning on the opening drive of extra time with a field goal, 31-28.

If this season were all that mattered, that would be the end of the story, two high powered offenses facing off in the big game. But the histories of Manning and Brees could not be more different. Peyton Manning, now in his twelfth season, has four MVPs and has passed for over 50,000 yards, one of only four quarterbacks in NFL history to achieve that milestone. He is also one of those few athletes who successfully endorses non-sports products like Master Card, Sony and Oreo cookies. If there is a knock on Manning, it is that he has only one Super Bowl ring, while in the same era, Tom Brady of the Patriots has three and Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers has two. If Manning and the Colts win this game, he adds a major achievement to a career that already deserves discussion when people rate the greatest quarterbacks of all time.

Drew Brees, on the other hand, has a career marked by bad luck and setbacks. Manning came to Indianapolis as the one and only golden boy, while Brees started his career in San Diego, taking the job from the beloved Doug Flutie. After a few seasons marked by injuries, the Chargers decided they needed a new quarterback and Brees lost his job to Philip Rivers. Brees became a free agent and was signed by the New Orleans Saints. As a franchise, the Saints have often struggled during their 43 year history, and this will be the team's first trip to the Super Bowl. For much of that tenure, the Saints were the only pro team in New Orleans (there is currently an NBA team in New Orleans that used to be in Charlotte), and though the fans had some famous protests against the team's incompetence from time to time, including attending games en masse wearing paper bags over their heads, the city really does love their Who Dat Saints.

I don't have a strong emotional attachment for either team, but I definitely don't have a team I'm rooting against. I hope it's a good game two weeks from now, and whoever wins, it will be a well-deserved vindication.

5 comments:

ken said...

The Saints have been my sympathy team for decades now. I have no idea how to deal with them as winners.

Zoey and Me said...

I hope the Saints win. I'm pretty upset with the Colts pulling their starters from the game to rest them, like kiddies who needed a nap or sumptin, so they would be healthy for the playoffs. The Jets won that game, by the way. And we will never know if the Colts could have matched the "he man" Dolphins who did have a perfect season because . . . they played all their games full boat. So when I look at a franchise massaging the fragile players so they can endure a 60 minutes that only counts to the gray suits, I say "wha, this is football"? It smacks. Now let's go one step further . . . do the fans get half their money back if the starters they came to see on sitting on the bench? I doubt it. Go Saints!

Matty Boy said...

Ken: Back in the 1960s, I picked sympathy baseball and football teams, the Baltimore Orioles and the Pittsburgh Steelers, largely because I liked their logos. The Orioles were a quality organization within a few years and the Steelers became good in the 1970s. It did change my relationship with them, but I enjoyed their success for a while at least.


Z&M: The whole perfect season thing is getting very weird. I too wish the Colts had gone for it, but not so much that I hope they lose now.

Abu Scooter said...

A couple more points about Drew Brees:

1. He's also been dealing with the death of his mother last August. He's done so quietly, and with an amazing amount of grace for someone in such a high-profile position.

2. It wasn't that long ago that NFL teams allowed new quarterbacks -- even high draft choices -- several years to develop, as Brees and Manning did. These days, new QBs are expected to succeed instantly. While that attitude has given us Mark Sanchez and Matt Ryan, it's also left us the likes of Jamarcus Russell and Brady Quinn. Maybe this Super Bowl will convice teams to return to their older, more patient ways.

Matty Boy said...

Good point about patience, Abu. In their first years, Joe Montana, Troy Aikman and Peyton Manning lead their teams to completely sucky records, and I would put the three of them in the top five QBs of the last 30 years, if not all time.